The disadvantages of the new pension system

What's really changing?

The new pension system raises many questions. Will your pension decrease? Will my pension become more uncertain? And why did the system need to change in the first place? Many concerns are understandable, but not all criticism tells the whole story. In this article, we discuss the main disadvantages of the new pension system and the nuances involved.

‍

Why is a new pension system being introduced?

The current pension system dates back to a time when people stayed with one employer their entire career and the economy was more predictable. That no longer fits the modern labor market. People change jobs more often, work more frequently as self-employed individuals, and accrue pension benefits less linearly. The Future of Pensions Act (WTP) aims to make the system more flexible and transparent.

Additionally, under the old system, pension funds had to maintain large buffers before they could increase pensions. As a result, indexations were withheld for years, even though there were sufficient funds available. The new system makes it possible to pass on returns to participants more quickly.

‍

Pensions will be less predictable

This is the most frequently mentioned disadvantage. In the new system, your pension will fluctuate more with stock market returns, interest rates, and the economy. This means that pensions can rise more quickly, but also fall more quickly. The sense of a fixed pension promise thus disappears.

Important nuance: even under the old system, there was no full guarantee. Pension funds could cut benefits, and indexation was not granted for years. The new system makes fluctuations more visible, but not necessarily greater.

‍

Greater reliance on investments

Many people perceive this as a risk. The pension outcome depends more heavily on how investments perform. A common question is what happens if the stock market crashes just before you retire. An important protection is built in here: as you get older, your pension assets are invested more defensively. The risk is reduced depending on age, so a stock market decline just before retirement has less impact than at a younger age.

‍

Older employees may experience disadvantages

Due to the transition to a flat-rate premium, young and old employees receive the same premium percentage. This is favorable for younger people because their contributions can generate returns for longer. Older employees miss out on this effect and may therefore experience disadvantages. That is why compensation schemes and grandfathering provisions exist. Employers and pension funds must make agreements about this. Without compensation, the transition could turn out unfavorably for some age groups, but this is not automatically the case.

‍

The system feels complex

New terms such as transferring existing pension rights, flat-rate premium, personal pension assets, and solidarity reserve make it difficult to understand exactly what is changing. This complexity causes uncertainty and distrust among many people. 

Pension funds are therefore investing heavily in communication. And although the transition is complicated, the eventual system will actually be more transparent. You will soon see more clearly what you have accrued and what you can expect.

‍

What are the benefits versus the drawbacks?

It's easy to focus solely on the risks, but the new system also brings improvements. Under the old system, funds had to maintain large buffers before they were allowed to index. In the new system, returns can be passed on more quickly, allowing pensions to increase faster during good times.

Additionally, you'll have a personal pension asset that you can track. This makes it clearer what you're accumulating and where you stand. For many, this is more reassuring than an abstract promise that might ultimately disappoint. Furthermore, the system is designed for a labor market where people frequently change jobs or work independently. Pension accrual becomes more personalized and less dependent on a single employer or fund.

‍

Want to know more about how pensions work for employees? Then check out pensions for employees or discover how pension investing works in practice.

‍